After being ‘silenced’ in Final, Connor McDavid’s name surfaces in bold Maple Leafs trade prediction

The heartbreak felt by Edmonton Oilers fans was achingly familiar as the team trudged off the ice in Florida, watching the Panthers celebrate their second consecutive Stanley Cup win.

Once again, the Oilers came up short on hockey’s grandest stage, falling 5-1 in Game 6 of the 2025 Final. And once again, the questions about the future of their franchise cornerstone, Connor McDavid, are growing louder.

Is Connor McDavid done with Edmonton? Stanley Cup loss fuels Maple Leafs trade speculation

Despite starting the series with a thrilling 4-3 overtime win, the Oilers couldn't maintain momentum. Sluggish starts, lack of scoring depth, and inconsistent goaltending plagued them throughout the series.

For Leon Draisaitl, comparisons to last year’s Game 7 loss didn’t matter—because the outcome remained unchanged. “We lost to a really good team. Nobody quit, nobody threw in the towel, but they’re a heck of a team,” said McDavid, tipping his cap to the Panthers.

“Very deserving. I don’t know what else to tell you, they were really good.”This defeat etched the Oilers into a painful chapter of NHL history, joining Boston and St.

Louis as the only teams in the post-expansion era to lose back-to-back Stanley Cup Final appearances. It also extended Canada’s Cup drought to a staggering 32 years, with Canadian-based teams now 0-7 in the final since Montreal’s triumph in 1993.

But beyond Edmonton’s struggles, the spotlight is now firmly fixed on McDavid. An NHL insider didn’t mince words about his legacy. “I feel for McDavid. Remarkable player,” said Josh Yohe.

“But he’s never won anything… He’s not Mario or Gretzky. Might want to pipe down comparisons until he wins it all.”McDavid’s status as one of the greatest talents in modern hockey remains undisputed—but the absence of a Stanley Cup weighs heavily on his resume. With only one year left on his current deal, speculation is swirling that the Toronto Maple Leafs may make a serious push for the generational talent. Bleacher Report’s Adam Gretz laid it out clearly: “If McDavid ever does become available, Toronto would have to find a way to get involved in the bidding.

”

Given that McDavid hails from the Greater Toronto Area, a return home could be more than a dream. Pairing him with Auston Matthews would give the Leafs an offensive powerhouse capable of changing the franchise’s fate. While the Oilers will likely do everything in their power to retain their captain, McDavid may seek a new chapter—especially if another season ends in disappointment.Should Toronto seize the chance to acquire Canada’s best player, it could ignite a dramatic shift in the NHL landscape. And while Oilers fans may view such a move as a betrayal, in the high-stakes world of professional hockey, legacies are ultimately built on championships.Also Read: Connor McDavid’s wife speaks out as Oilers suffer another devastating Stanley Cup Final heartbreak