MLB trade rumors: Cleveland Guardians predicted to land $15.65 million Seattle Mariners star outfielder to bolster squad strength ahead of offseason

The Cleveland Guardians are looking for more power before the 2026 season. One player linked to them is Seattle Mariners outfielder Randy Arozarena, who recently settled at $15.65 million in arbitration.Cleveland needs a reliable bat behind José Ramírez. The team struggled to score last season and relied too much on contact hitting. Adding a player like Arozarena would address that issue.

Proposed trade and players involved

One suggested deal would send Randy Arozarena to Cleveland Guardians. In return, Seattle Mariners would receive catcher Bo Naylor and left-handed pitcher Kolby Allard.Naylor, 26, hit 15 home runs in limited action in 2025 and can serve as a backup to Cal Raleigh.

Allard, 28, gives Seattle another left-handed option on the mound alongside Luis Castillo, George Kirby, and Logan Gilbert.The trade works without involving top prospects. It also fits Seattle’s recent moves, including adding Brendan Donovan and re-signing Josh Naylor.

How Randy Arozarena fits in Cleveland Guardians

Arozarena would likely play right field or serve as designated hitter. He could bat second, between Steven Kwan and José Ramírez.Cleveland finished near the bottom of the league in runs last season.

Arozarena’s numbers—27 home runs and 31 stolen bases in 2025—would help balance the lineup.He is 30 and entering a contract year. His presence would also make things easier for hitters like Kyle Manzardo.

What Seattle Mariners gets out of it

Seattle Mariners would be moving a player close to free agency for younger, controllable pieces. Naylor adds depth behind Raleigh, and Allard strengthens pitching options.The Mariners still have enough outfield depth with Julio Rodríguez, Luke Raley, and Dominic Canzone.

The move also helps with payroll.

Randy Arozarena’s 2025 stats

His walk rate (16.3%) and speed suggest he can still produce around 25 home runs and 80 RBIs.

Lineup impact for Cleveland Guardians

Pros and cons of the deal

For Cleveland, the benefit is clear. They add power without giving up top prospects and give Ramírez more support. The downside is losing depth and taking on a player who hit .238 last season.For Seattle, the trade brings younger players and helps with future payroll. The risk is losing Arozarena’s power and speed, and relying on limited catcher depth if Raleigh is unavailable.Also read: MLB trade rumors: Detroit Tigers might acquire $340 million San Diego Padres superstar to replace Miguel Cabrera and boost their lineupCleveland improves immediately with this move. Seattle gains pieces that help over a longer period. Both teams address their needs, but in different ways.