NFL underdog Tyson Bagent shocks Chicago as the Bears suddenly boast the league's best quarterback duo

The Chicago Bears’ 38–0 preseason demolition of the Buffalo Bills was expected to be Caleb Williams’ coronation at Soldier Field. Instead, Tyson Bagent—the undrafted quarterback from Shepherd University—delivered 205 yards and a touchdown, turning a routine exhibition into a reminder that Chicago may have the NFL’s most intriguing quarterback depth.

From small-school shepherd roots to stealing the show in Chicago

Two years ago, Bagent was an unknown rookie fighting for a roster spot. On Saturday, he ran Chicago’s offense with precision, extending drives and punishing Buffalo’s defense. His performance wasn’t just impressive—it was proof that small-school pedigree doesn’t limit NFL potential. In a sport obsessed with draft status, Bagent continues to rewrite the script.

How Tyson Bagent made Ben Johnson’s new offense look effortless

What separated Bagent was how comfortably he worked inside Ben Johnson’s new system.

Quick reads, crisp timing, and fearless throws downfield kept the offense flowing. “He’s confident, he’s decisive, and he makes the offense click,” Johnson said. The trust from a first-year head coach signals that Bagent is more than an understudy—he’s a reliable driver of this scheme.Bagent’s value extends beyond preseason box scores. In a league where losing a starter can sink an entire season, the Bears have security others envy.

“With Tyson, we know we’re in good hands if his number gets called,” receiver Olamide Zaccheaus said. That kind of assurance makes him one of the most valuable No. 2 quarterbacks in football.

From internet cult hero to Chicago’s most unexpected quarterback threat

Last season, “Bagent Mania” felt like a quirky fan movement celebrating an underdog. Against Buffalo, it transformed into something more serious. His composure and accuracy suggest staying power, and that could spark debates about how central he might become to Chicago’s long-term plans.

He is no longer just a novelty act; he is a problem defenses must prepare for.

What Tyson Bagent’s rise really means for the Bears’ future and the NFL

Preseason often gets dismissed as a tune-up, but for Bagent it feels like a turning point. His poise and production have made him one of the most intriguing storylines of August. For the Bears, it’s a luxury dilemma: Williams may be the franchise face, but Bagent has shown the spotlight in Chicago can’t belong to just one quarterback.Also read:Joe Milton’s inaccuracy is silently wrecking Dallas Cowboys receivers’ roster chances