NHL Rumor: NHL star Sam Bennett avoids Maple Leafs in surprising free agent update

Florida Panthers forward Sam Bennett just helped his team win their second straight Stanley Cup. While fans are celebrating, talks about his future have already started. With his current contract ending soon, people want to know where he might play next.

One NHL insider has now shared a big update that’s getting a lot of attention—especially from Toronto Maple Leafs fans. But it’s not the news they were hoping for.

Sam Bennett reportedly not interested in joining Toronto Maple Leafs

On Wednesday, June 19, 2025, NHL insider Andy Strickland posted an update on social media platform X (formerly Twitter) that sparked strong reactions. Strickland wrote, “Hearing Toronto will not be on Sam Bennett’s list of free agent destinations, if unable to come to terms with Florida and he becomes a UFA.”Sam Bennett’s four-year deal worth $17.7 million is coming to an end soon, and he will become an unrestricted free agent if he and the Panthers don’t agree on a new contract.

Bennett is coming off a strong playoff run where he won the Conn Smythe Trophy. He scored 15 goals during the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs and played a key role in helping the Panthers win back-to-back titles. Despite his strong season, it seems he has no plans to move to Toronto.

At 28 years old, Bennett is expected to get a big contract this summer. But fans in Toronto might be disappointed if they were hoping to see him join the Maple Leafs.

Frank Seravalli explains why Florida has an edge in keeping Sam Bennett

NHL analyst Frank Seravalli gave more details about why Florida might be able to keep Sam Bennett, even if other teams offer more money. Speaking on Sportsnet earlier this week, Seravalli said, “They’ve got the no state income tax advantage.” He added that Bennett could sign for eight years at $7.5 million per season and still earn more money than he would elsewhere.Also Read: NHL Trade Rumors: Toronto Maple Leafs Eye Sam Bennett As Potential Mitch Marner Replacement In Free Agency Shake-UpHe explained how taxes in different cities affect NHL contracts. “One team might offer seven years at $10 million, but after taxes, that could be less than Florida’s offer,” Seravalli said. This makes it harder for teams in high-tax places like Toronto to attract big names.This matches what Andy Strickland said Bennett might not even consider Toronto if he leaves Florida. His choice may not be just about hockey, but also about money and comfort.