Steelers ready to dump indecisive Aaron Rodgers for failed Colts QB in shocking $34M gamble

With the 2025 NFL season fast approaching, the Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves at a dangerous crossroads. As Aaron Rodgers continues to stall his return, whispers around the league suggest the Steelers may be preparing to move on—and in a bold direction.

The franchise is reportedly eyeing Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson as a potential long-term solution, a move that could reshape the team's future.

Aaron Rodgers keeps Steelers waiting as QB market dries up

Aaron Rodgers has yet to commit to joining the Steelers, leaving Pittsburgh in quarterback limbo. The free-agent market has thinned out, with veterans like Carson Wentz and Ryan Tannehill offering little upside. Rather than settle for aging stopgaps, the Steelers are reportedly considering more ambitious options—like trading for former top-5 pick Anthony Richardson.Richardson, drafted fourth overall in 2023, is entering his third year but hasn’t quite lived up to the hype. Injuries and inconsistent play led to him losing the starting job to Joe Flacco in Indianapolis, and now he finds himself in a heated battle with Daniel Jones for the QB1 role. If the Colts decide Jones is the better fit, Richardson could become expendable—and the Steelers may be ready to pounce.

Anthony Richardson’s fit with the Steelers and Arthur Smith’s offense

Despite his early struggles, Anthony Richardson remains one of the most physically gifted quarterbacks in the league.

With elite athleticism, a cannon for an arm, and the ability to extend plays, he possesses the kind of dual-threat skillset that offensive coordinator Arthur Smith has successfully worked with in the past.Richardson is still under his rookie contract—a four-year, $34 million deal with two seasons remaining and a fifth-year option. That affordability makes him an enticing option, especially if Pittsburgh sees him as their quarterback of the future.To potentially sway Rodgers to commit, the Steelers are also rumored to be targeting wide receiver Allen Lazard. The former Packers and Jets wideout is one of Rodgers’ most trusted targets. Bringing him to Pittsburgh could serve a dual purpose: strengthening the receiving corps and giving Rodgers a familiar weapon to reignite chemistry with.Also Read: Diggs brothers in hot water: Stefon Diggs’ drama now mirrored by Trevon Diggs' OTA troubleAs the regular season opener against the Jets on September 7 looms large, all eyes are on Pittsburgh’s next move. Will they finally get a commitment from Rodgers—or turn the page with a bold gamble on Richardson’s untapped potential?