“Worst-case”: Aaron Rodgers signing sparks fears of a risky gamble disguised as a Super Bowl push

After months of speculation, four-time NFL MVP Aaron Rodgers has officially signed with the Pittsburgh Steelers — and reactions across the league range from cautious optimism to outright concern.

While Steelers fans are eager for a return to postseason prominence, some former players and analysts believe the move could be a high-risk gamble with mixed rewards.

Ryan Clark blasts the signing as ‘worst-case scenario’ for the Steelers’ future

Former Steelers safety and ESPN analyst Ryan Clark didn’t hold back, describing the Rodgers move as potentially setting the franchise back long-term, “Aaron Rodgers signing with the Steelers is the worst-case scenario. I think he’ll play good enough, & the team will be just good enough to miss out on a franchise guy next year!”

Clark’s warning touches on a common concern — Rodgers might raise Pittsburgh’s floor just enough to keep them competitive without lifting them into true Super Bowl contention, ultimately costing them a shot at drafting a long-term quarterback.

Dez Bryant sees potential but throws shade at Aaron Rodgers' recent struggles

Retired wideout Dez Bryant offered a nuanced take, defending Rodgers from critics who blamed him for underwhelming performances in New York, “I think Aaron Rodgers will have success because he’s going to be able to implement the things he’s comfortable with and control the offense the way he wants.”Bryant emphasized that Rodgers never had the trust or system fit with the Jets that he’s likely to get in Pittsburgh — especially under Mike Tomlin, with whom Rodgers shares a mutual respect.

Steelers go all-in with DK Metcalf, Watt, and Heyward on aging timeline

Robert Griffin III added context to the front office's urgency, noting that veterans like T.J. Watt and Cameron Heyward are entering what could be their final window to chase a championship in Pittsburgh, “For Cameron Heyward (36) and TJ Watt (30) this is likely their last chance to win it all in a Steelers uniform.”With DK Metcalf arriving via trade and tight end Pat Freiermuth ready to be a primary target, Pittsburgh is clearly pushing its chips in for 2025.NFL Network’s Stacey Dales believes Rodgers “has a lot to prove,” while former Packers QB Kurt Benkert suggests Pittsburgh’s defense might be one of the best Rodgers has ever played alongside. If the run game can deliver and Rodgers remains healthy, the Steelers could be a dark horse Super Bowl contender — or an overhyped flameout.One thing’s certain: the Rodgers era in Pittsburgh is here, and the pressure has never been higher.Also Read: Aaron Rodgers contract details: Why the Steelers’ one-year gamble could define their season and legacy