SC to hear pleas challenging Bihar electoral roll revision on August 12, 13; says ‘will step in if there is mass exclusion’

As the court took up the matter on Tuesday, Senior Advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, appearing for the ECI, submitted that the draft has been advertised and given to political parties.

Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MP Manoj Jha, said those who have been left out must have a chance to submit objections. “They will have the right. Who said they won’t?” Justice Kant said, adding, “The moment they deviate from the notification, we will interfere.”

To this, Sibal said, “We don’t know who has been left,” and asked if the ECI had given the names of those excluded. Dwivedi replied, “It won’t be given to you. Take from the website.”

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for the petitioner Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR), submitted that according to the ECI, 65 lakh people have not submitted the enumeration forms as they are either dead or have permanently shifted elsewhere. Contending that those excluded will have to apply afresh, he wondered how they will come to know whether they are in the draft.

Justice Kant said that the ECI is a constitutional body and “we would deem their action will be in accordance with the law.” He assured that the court is there to take care of any concern. “We are here, we will hear you,” he stated.

Justice Bagchi said, “January 2025 list is the starting point if there was no SIR. Draft list will be published by ECI. Your apprehension is 65 lakh-odd voters will not feature… They (ECI) are seeking correction vis-a-vis 2025 entry. We are overviewing the thing as a judicial authority. If there is mass exclusion, we will step in. Bring 15 people saying they are alive but left out.”

The ECI counsel, however, said there is a 30-day window for filing objections and that the petitioners should help with adding names.

Justice Kant stated that political parties should operate like NGOs during the process.

Sibal said the petitioners will have no problem if the ECI mentions who were excluded. Justice Kant then said, “If the draft list is conspicuously silent, you will bring (it) to our attention.”

Dwivedi said the final number would be made public only after the objections are considered. “Once objections are considered, a real picture would come as to who has been excluded. At least by September 15, we are expecting (the final list),” he added.