MLB trade rumors: Boston Red Sox predicted to land $210 million New York Mets All-Star to replace Rafael Devers’ lost offense

When the Boston Red Sox traded Rafael Devers back in June, the move shocked fans and analysts alike. Many believed Boston had effectively waved the white flag on the 2025 season. Yet, against the odds, the team clawed its way to its first playoff berth in four years - only to see that run cut short due to a lack of offensive firepower.Now, with Devers gone and Roman Anthony sidelined by injury, baseball writer Jake Elman of Fansided believes the Red Sox must make a bold move this offseason: signing New York Mets slugger Pete Alonso.

Why the Boston Red Sox Need Pete Alonso

The Boston Red Sox’s offense sputtered without Devers anchoring the lineup. Despite flashes of brilliance from a young roster, the team’s inability to generate consistent run support proved costly in the postseason.Alonso, a five-time All-Star, has officially opted out of his Mets contract and is entering free agency. That news has turned heads in Boston, where fans and media alike see him as a natural fit to fill the void left by Devers.Elman summarized the potential fit perfectly, writing, “There’s no denying that Alonso, a durable first baseman who has averaged 39 home runs, 114 RBIs, and an .842 OPS over the last five seasons, is a perfect fit for Boston.” (H/t: Sporting News)

A Powerhouse Bat That Boston Desperately Needs

Alonso’s power numbers speak for themselves. Over his last five seasons, he’s been among MLB’s most reliable sluggers.

His combination of home run production and RBI consistency could immediately elevate Boston’s offensive potential.

Alonso’s arrival would address two glaring issues for Boston: their lack of a true cleanup hitter and instability at first base. Triston Casas, once seen as the future at the position, has struggled to find his footing in the majors, leaving the Red Sox searching for answers.

Fixing First Base and Adding Depth at DH

Signing Alonso would allow Boston to stabilize its infield while adding flexibility to the lineup.

He could anchor first base and also contribute as a designated hitter when needed - something the team has struggled to manage effectively in recent years.Moreover, Alonso’s durability makes him a low-risk investment for a franchise that has suffered from inconsistent health among its key players.

Beyond Alonso: Why Boston Must Keep Bregman Too

Some analysts have suggested Boston pursue Alonso only if Alex Bregman leaves in free agency. However, as Elman argues, that approach would be shortsighted.

The Red Sox need both stars if they hope to make a legitimate championship push.The message is clear: if Boston truly wants to chase its tenth World Series title, it can’t afford to settle for an either-or scenario. The front office must bring back Bregman and land Alonso to reestablish themselves as a powerhouse in the American League.Also read: MLB trade rumors: New York Yankees predicted to land $4.175 million All-Star to bolster squad and replace BellingerBoston’s unexpected playoff run in 2025 proved they’re not far off from serious contention. But to stay there, the front office has to act decisively. Signing Pete Alonso would send a strong message - not just to fans, but to the entire league - that the Red Sox are all-in on building a contender again. If they succeed, Boston won’t just be replacing Rafael Devers’ lost offense. They’ll be redefining the identity of a franchise hungry for banner No.

10.