When Stardom, Sequels and Hype Collide: The Unpredictability of the Box Office

In cinema, there are few guarantees. A star-studded cast, a franchise with proven history, or even the magic of a sequel none of it ensures box office gold. If anything, the recent trajectory of some of the biggest films across Hindi and Tamil cinema reiterates an age-old truth: films are unpredictable creatures.Take Shah Rukh Khan’s Jawan. Released in 2023, it carried the aura of a superstar who had just returned triumphantly with Pathaan. Expectations were sky-high, and the opening day lived up to them. Jawan stormed the Hindi box office with Rs 65.5 crore on Day 1. Day 2 brought in another Rs 46.23 crore, cementing its dominance. Its first week haul of Rs 347.98 ( Hindi) crore in India was proof that audiences were willing to embrace SRK in a larger-than-life avatar once again.Contrary see films like Salman Khan’s Sikandar the film was ‘Bhai’s’ film and was released on EID but lost steam once it crossed Rs 100 crore mark. Also Hrithik Roshan and Jr. NTR’s War 2, a film tied to the highly successful YRF Spy Universe. The original War was a blockbuster, and with War 2 bringing together Hrithik and Telugu superstar Jr. NTR, anticipation was immense. Yet, the film’s Day 1 Hindi numbers told a different story: Rs 29 crore. Day 2 saw major improvement with Rs 44 crore, but the start was far from the record-shattering expectations. Clearly, a sequel with big names and an established universe did not automatically translate into Jawan-like fireworks.

Though War 2 did manage to cross Rs 100 crore mark thanks to Telugu version chipping in a big way courtesy the presence of Jr.NTR . The total collection of the film at the end of day 2 was Rs 108 crore. Then, there’s Rajinikanth, the man often described as a phenomenon rather than a star. His 2018 magnum opus 2.0 was touted as one of the most expensive Indian films ever made, with cutting-edge VFX and the legacy of Enthiran (Robot) behind it.

Yet, in Tamil Nadu, its Day 1 collection was Rs 23 crore and Day 2 dropped sharply to Rs 12 crore.But it was the Hindi version which picked up the slack as combined day 1 was at Rs 60.25 crore and day 2 was Rs 38 crore with overall week 1 collection being Rs 303.25 crore.

Despite the presence of the biggest superstar in the south, backed by a blockbuster franchise, one can face unpredictability at the turnstiles.Fast forward to 2024, and Rajinikanth is back with Coolie.

Expectations, once again, were through the roof. And this time, the box office responded differently. The film collected Rs 44.5 crore on Day 1 and Rs 33.5 crore on Day 2 for Tamil version, taking its two-day tally to Rs 78 crore, whereas the overall total across languages stood at Rs 118.5 crore. Put together, these four films two Tamil, two Hindipaint an intriguing picture of the unpredictability of cinema.Stardom Is a Magnet, Not a GuaranteeThe simplest way to describe the Indian box office is this: stardom guarantees attention, but not results.

Shah Rukh Khan, Rajinikanth, Hrithik Roshan, Jr. NTR—all command legions of fans. Their films open with massive hype. But sustaining momentum depends on how well the film connects with audiences across demographics.In Jawan, Shah Rukh Khan’s double role, Atlee’s mass action storytelling, and a strong blend of emotion and spectacle clicked with both single screens and multiplex audiences. In contrast, War 2’s initial response suggested that despite its scale, audiences weren’t swept away in the same way right from the start.The Franchise Factor: Friend or Foe?Franchises come with baggage sometimes a boon, sometimes a burden. 2.0 had the goodwill of Robot behind it, yet many found its storytelling uneven despite technical brilliance. The result: a big opening, followed by a noticeable drop.On the other hand, War 2 shows the challenge of sustaining a cinematic universe. The first War raised expectations sky-high, and audiences came in hoping for something bigger and fresher.

If the film doesn’t meet that expectation in the opening days, it takes longer to build word of mouth.Sequels, therefore, can’t merely ride the wave of their predecessors. They need to re-invent while respecting the original. Audiences today are sharper, less forgiving, and far more demanding.But as to every law there is an exception, one can see the magic of sequels in Allu Arjun’s Pushpa 2 or Prabhas’s Baahubali 2 or Yash’s KGF 2. Regional Variations MatterAnother factor in box office unpredictability is geography.

Rajinikanth’s 2.0 may not have matched the sky-high expectations in Tamil Nadu initially, but its Hindi version performed strongly, showing how reception differs across markets. Similarly, Coolie’s thunderous start in Tamil shows the localized power of Rajinikanth’s stardom, which remains intact even after decades.For Jawan, Shah Rukh Khan bridged these divides and so did Ranbir Kapoor’s Animal. With its pan-India approach releasing in Hindi, Tamil, and Telugu it tapped into multiple markets at once.

That’s one reason its first week collection was staggering.Audience Sentiment Is KingPerhaps the most critical factor in this unpredictability is audience sentiment. Social media, reviews, and word-of-mouth spread faster today than ever before. If audiences love the content, collections soar. If they’re disappointed, drops are immediate and sharp.For trade analysts, producers, and even fans, these contrasting examples highlight why predicting box office performance is a gamble. There are too many moving parts—release timing, competition, critical reception, fan expectations, and even external factors like ticket pricing or holiday periods.No amount of stardom can guarantee a Rs 400 crore week.

No franchise, however celebrated, is immune to fatigue. And no superstar, however legendary, can be certain of the audience’s mood on release day.

"Get the latest news updates on Times of India, including reviews of the movie Coolie and War 2."