NHL analyst urges patience in Lane Hutson contract talks, calls Erik Karlsson’s $92 million deal a “mistake”

The Montreal Canadiens are in no rush to lock down Lane Hutson to a massive long-term deal, despite his sensational rookie season that earned him the 2024–25 Calder Trophy. NHL insider Stu Cowan believes the Canadiens should take a measured approach, even as the 21-year-old defenseman’s stock continues to rise.

Why the Canadiens are taking their time with Lane Hutson’s contract negotiations

Hutson, who posted six goals and 60 assists for 66 points in his first season, has quickly become one of the most promising young blueliners in the league. But with only one year of NHL experience, Cowan feels a cautious strategy is smart."If you're offering him eight years at $8 million or $9 million, I don't think you're insulting the kid, right?" Cowan said on The Sick podcast. "That's a lot of money for a kid with one season in the NHL, 21 years old, size worries or concerns."

Cowan warned that waiting could increase the cost. If Hutson replicates his rookie performance this season, a midyear extension could easily surpass $10 million annually. However, he stressed that rushing into an eight-year commitment isn’t necessary at this stage.Comparing Hutson to Colorado Avalanche star Cale Makar, Cowan noted that Makar signed a six-year, $9 million AAV deal at 23. When host Tony Marinaro brought up Erik Karlsson’s $11.5 million AAV contract worth $92 million, Cowan didn’t hesitate: “Yeah, that is a mistake.”

The risk-reward balance for both sides in the negotiations

While patience could benefit the Canadiens, it comes with risk for Hutson. Cowan pointed out that an injury before signing could cost the young defenseman millions. Still, he believes both sides will eventually agree to a deal: “I’m sure at the end of the day the Canadiens are going to sign Lane Hutson.”Hutson’s rookie season was historic—his 60 assists tied Larry Murphy for the most ever by a rookie defenseman. Former Habs legend Serge Savard even claimed, “He’s probably the most talented player the Canadiens have had since Guy Lafleur.”Also Read: NHL trade rumors heat up as Carey Price’s contract linked to potential Chicago Blackhawks dealThe challenge for Montreal’s front office is finding a deal that rewards Hutson’s early brilliance without taking on unnecessary long-term risk. For now, the Canadiens appear ready to let time—and performance—guide the price tag.