Pete Alonso contract sparks backlash as MLB expert reveals Mets’ biggest 2025 failure

Did the Mets drop the ball when re-signing Pete Alonso? After a tense offseason of talks, the star slugger agreed to a two-year, $54 million deal with an opt-out clause. But one expert says the team showed disrespect by not offering a long-term contract upfront.

Now, with Alonso hitting .292, driving 18 homers and adding 65 RBIs by June 27, many wonder if the Mets misjudged his value .

Pete Alonso and New York Mets faced ‘offseason disrespect’ criticism

Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly named the Mets’ handling of Alonso’s deal one of MLB’s “10 Biggest Fails” of 2025. Kelly wrote that teams needing power left first base untouched in talks with Alonso, saying it was “egg on your face” now that he’s off to a career year. Alonso hit 34 homers in 2024 with a .788 OPS, showing postseason strength, yet still didn’t land a big offer during the offseason.Alonso’s current numbers back up Kelly’s point: as of June 27, he slashes .292 with a .933 OPS, 18 homers and 65 RBIs, the best of his career. Kelly warned the Mets that once Alonso opts out, he’d likely seek a bigger deal, leaving New York out in the cold.Also Read: Seattle Mariners Star Cal Raleigh Shocks Fans With Home Run Derby Debut And Surprising Role For Dad Todd Raleigh

Pete Alonso’s strong season supports expert warnings

Pete Alonso, age 30, re-signed with the Mets in February on his current deal that runs through 2026 with an opt-out after 2025. Early in 2025, he’s already hitting better than ever.

He leads the National League in doubles and ranks top five in OPS (.933).

This season also saw praise from Mets president David Stearns, who said Alonso’s performance was taken “to another level.” Stearns also noted that contract talks remain off the table . The short-term deal appears to have saved money now, but it may cost in the long run if Alonso leaves and signs a longer deal elsewhere.